Tuesday, August 27, 2013

The Dilemma of Development in the Rainforest


What happens when you live in the jungle beyond where the road ends, where there is no electricity, and your child gets ill? Chances are you get in a canoe and travel down the river to the nearest large city and figure out some way to pay for the services, possibly with the combination of fish, yucca, and fruit--all of which are plentiful near your home.  That was 10 years ago. 

Fast forward to the present and we now see a road carved through the primary rainforest to your house. Electricity was installed two months ago in your community, and your youngest children have been able to attend school right across the river, as opposed to the 5 hour trek that your older children used to make each week to a boarding school.  It would seem, by external measurements, that your life is improving, that you are taking advantage of the wave of development that is washing over Ecuador.

But let's look closer.  Your production methods on the three acres of farmland that you have always maintained are still the same. You use a machete to cut down weeds, bury new yucca shoots, and cut grapefruits from the shade tree towering over your house. However, selling a sack of robusta coffee beans and criollo cocoa every few months is no longer enough to cover your needs. Sure, you can still eat well from the chickens that run through your fields and the bountiful variety of fruits and vegetables that grow on your 50 acres of rainforest and cleared land, but now you have other expenses.  

When electricity came into the community, you purchased a refrigerator, a flat screen TV, and a computer in the provincial capital.  A savings and loan cooperative in the city loaned you the money at 20% annually, which means you will be paying them back $45 a month for the next 3 and a half years.

Your children also cost more now--they attend a public school for which they need uniforms each year.  Whereas the missionary-run boarding school your eldest children attended provided uniforms, the government's free uniform program does not extend to your community and you must invest $100 every September on uniforms and school supplies for each of your 4 school-age children.

There are other needs, too--those 90-minute trips into town each month on a bus to make your loan payment make you wish you had a motorcycle, and each time you are in town, you usually spend a few dollars on food or clothes or something for the house. Looking at your current situation, you wonder how you could earn more money to purchase those things that would make life easier.

A logging company came by your community last week and offered you $2,500 for all the trees on your land.  Doing the math, that would allow you to buy a few pigs to raise and sell for additional income, plant another acre of cocoa, and ensure your children go to school next month. While you love the forest, where your family has lived for generations, you wonder if this might be the best choice for your children.  Right now you are debating sending only 2 of the children to school next month, and the income from selling yucca, corn, plantains, and pineapple in the market downstream barely covers your monthly loan payment.  With development and new opportunities you have more expensive, and maintaining primary rainforest on your land is not making you any money. 

So therein lies the question--what do you do when development brings new opportunities, but the old production methods do not result in the income you need to fully participate in the new opportunities that have come with development? 

No comments:

Post a Comment